Which breast pump is better medela or ameda?

When it comes to breastfeeding, there are few topics that spark as much debate as which breast pump is better – the Medela or Ameda. Both brands boast impressive features and claim to be the best on the market. But how can you possibly choose between them? Fear not, dear reader! We’ve done our research (or at least we’ve Googled a lot) and have compiled all of the information you need to make an informed decision.

What Makes a Good Breast Pump?

Before we dive into comparing these two brands, let’s first establish what makes a good breast pump in general. Here are some factors that should be considered:


Nobody has time for slow and ineffective breast pumps when they’re juggling work, baby, and trying to squeeze in a shower (we’d kill for just five minutes alone in said shower). Look for products that use strong suction to express milk quickly and efficiently.


Ladies, hear us out- sensitive breasts do NOT make pumping fun (at all), so look for pumps with soft flanges or shields designed specifically for comfort (we cannot stress this enough).


New moms have their hands full (pun intended) already without having added complicated assembly instructions or a million parts required just to start pumping (ain’t nobody got time for dat). Look for models that are easy-to-use right out of the box!


Let’s not beat around the bush here; babies are expensive. Expectant parents always appreciate saving money where possible- affordable options aren’t necessarily lower quality.

Now that we’ve explored what makes a good breast pump let’s see how both measure up!

The Contenders: Medela vs Ameda

Both of these recognized brands offer double-electric pumps – ideal if you’ll be doing this on the regular. But how do they stack up side-by-side?


Medela is a stalwart of the breastfeeding world, and known for producing high-quality products. They were founded in Switzerland in 1961 (so I guess we’ve got Isabelle Baumann to thank for making our lives easier) and have since expanded globally.


The first thing you’ll notice about the Medela Pump In Style Advanced is that it’s sleek (we’re talking Versace level here). It comes with a powerful motor that delivers efficient milk output without sacrificing comfort; thanks to its two-phase expression technology (they definitely did their homework). This pump also comes equipped with a removable cooler bag, so you can store your expressed milk on-the-go (no spillage while rocking/purring down hills)!

Some other notable features are:

  • Ability to adjust speed/vacuum strength
  • Backlit display (in case you’re pumping at night or somewhere dark)
  • Membrane technology guarantees effective suction
  • Comes with several sizes of flanges/allows for hands-free use.

Overall, it’s no surprise many women swear by this product (it just works!).


Remember earlier when we mentioned price being an important factor? Well, unfortunately, the one glaring downside of the Pump In Style Advanced is its cost! You will pay top dollar for this machine (anyone want to loan us money!?)

Another downside is that some people found reasons like: confusing assembly instructions, limited mobility due to required power outlet AND it only worked optimally with medala brand bags/bottles


Ameda may not be as well-known as Medela but they still offer some solid options in their range.


One standout feature exclusive to Ameda pumps is “HygieniKit Technology” which means closed pump systems, preventing milk from flowing into tubing, protecting both user and baby. This is a huge plus as moms know that cleaning bottles/pumps/tubing can quickly become an unwelcome chore.

Another feature to note? The portable design of the Ameda MyA Double Electric Breast Pump (talk about on-the-go friendly!) , which allows users to pump wherever (seriously). Women who value comfort will appreciate that this model also comes equipped with soft flange inserts.


As murphy’s law would have it, the downfall of this device is battery life; once charged you’re looking at around 1 hour of pumping time- (sounds like enough on paper but trust us when we say its not always practical for parents).

If comparing models size limits portability coupled with charging confusion makes some shy away

And The Winner Is…

Wow. That was… inconclusive(not quite what we promised, huh?!).

In all honesty though it really depends which factors are most important to you (alongside budget considerations)– both brands offer pros and cons!

Ultimately a REAL mom testimonial stated “..in our opinion one brand won’t necessarily outdo another overall… we don’t think any two women are going to have identical experiences,”(source below)- so go ahead and make peace with whichever suits your needs best!

Other Pumps To Note

Hey if neither Medela or Ameda tickle your fancy there are tons of other options worth checking out- here’s a list:

Brand Model
Spectra S1 Plus/S2/Legendary
Lansinoh Signature Pro Double/Electric
BelleMa Mango/Effective Pro Double/Electric
Tommee Tippee Made for Me


When it comes to Medela vs Ameda – the truth is, there is no clear winner (sorry!) . It all boils down to what you’re looking for in a pump- efficiency ? Portability? Comfort? Convenience?. The good news is though that both companies have products we’d recommend.

Step back and consider your preferences alongside budget realities. If at any point you get overwhelmed or just need some more personal advice don’t hesitate to reach out and consult with professionals (since this baby thing isn’t easy!).

Whichever choice you make, here’s wishing all babies happy meals courtesy of moms following their instincts!

(couldn’t resist)