Land of Confusion...

Current | Politics

madisonbandw111605.gifMadison's Common Council spent the better part of tonight listening to public testimony on the city's 2006 capital and operating budget. Kristian of The Daily Page blogged live, summarizing the testimony of Madison's residents.

The scene in the hallway prior to the meeting could best be described as the land of confusion. Numerous people, coming to testify on various budget items and amendments, found a short list of "items of interest" (to whom?) created by city staff, a long list of proposed amendments, and registration forms with little explanation as to how to proceed. Missing from the scene were city staff available to answer questions or assist residents with the registration process.

Some of the registrants had tried to find out more about the process for the evening prior to the meeting. Alder Konkel tried to help inquiring residents, sending the following email to Council President Van Rooy and various city staff members on Saturday:

Quote:
When people register on tuesday, are we going to take public speakers amendment by amendment, or are we going to let all the public speakers speak first and then work our way through they amendments? Will the
registration forms have a place to say which amendment they want to speak to? Since most people will be there for the operating budget, can we do that first? What's the plan?
b
Her inquiry went unanswered until today, only about 7 hours before the meeting, when she received the following response from Paul Van Rooy:
Quote:
Brenda:

My intentions are to take all testimony on the budget at the beginning of the meeting. When testimony is done we will begin deliberation. If we end up going to a second night, my intention is to resume
deliberations, but not to take additional testimony at that time. Hopefully we will finish the budget and adopt it tonight.

Paul Van Rooy

This surely did not answer the question of how testimony and related registration would be handled.

The registration slips found on the tables outside Council chambers asked constituents to mark "support" or "oppose" to a specified agenda item and individual budget amendments. Conversation in the hallway included questions about whether amendments supported and opposed should be listed on the same form; whether those wishing to speak could speak on only one item at a time or all amendments together; if one could speak on some amendments listed on the registration form and list support or opposition for others without including them when speaking; questioning whether the 5 minute limit was for capital and operating budgets together or 5 minutes was given for each; general discussion of how to best complete the forms so they make sense; and much frustration over the lack of assistance in understanding and completing the registration process.

Some were still confused when they had their turns to speak. At least 2 speakers returned to their seats thinking that they would have another opportunity to speak on additional amendments.

A large crowd turned out for the meeting, many of whom do not ordinarily attend. This sort of civic involvement should be encouraged with a friendly welcome and some assistance with the process, rather than stifled by confusion and frustration.

If city staff is unavailable to assist residents with registration, perhaps the city could enlist willing volunteers to greet residents and help them better understand how to make their voices heard.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Kristian and yourself

Krisitian and yourself deserve a great deal of respect for sitting through that so we don't have to. Thanks to you both for the summary. Much sympathy to those that want to comment on budget issues and have to deal with the lack of organization. But hey, this is Madtown!

Non-Speaking Registrants

I just got an email bringing to my attention a critical detail that I neglected to notice. Prior to deliberating on the budget, no mention was made of those who registered but did not speak. Therefore, these people's support or opposition to various budget amendments was ignored and unavailable to alders prior to voting.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

*
*
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


*

  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dd><a> <b> <dl> <dt> <i> <u> <ul><br><p> <div> <u> <object> <strike> <img> <embed> <param>
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text, URLs will be automatically converted to links
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may use [inline:xx] tags to display uploaded files or images inline.